Comments on and critiques the findings in MedPAC's Medicare in Rural America. The authors believe that while the MedPAC report helps set a framework for analysis, it is not a definitive treatise on the role of Medicare in rural health.

Among its findings: most of MedPAC's recommendations would have positive impacts on healthcare for rural beneficiaries, others would do no harm, others could be strengthened, and a few, particularly those relating to access to services, "suffer from disparities and weaknesses." Report produced by the RUPRI Rural Health Panel.